Topper Copies

With the help of literary and archaeological sources, critically evaluate the hypothesis that there was urban decay during c. 300-600 CE.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

R.S. Sharma has argued that there were two phases of deurbanisation after 3rd century CE - first one between 300 - 600 CE and second one but after 600 CE.

Yes: There was Urban decay (300 -600 CE)

Archaeological Evidence - R.S. Sharma has highlighted lack of archaeological evidence in terms of structures, roads, palaces, etc that are markers of urban life from the 300-600 CE period - City of Vaishali (modern Basarh in Bihar), which has yielded large number of coins in other phases, but very few in 300-600 CE period - Inscriptions from the period contain lesser references to traders and merchants - Large number of land grants in the period suggest agricultural expansion and hence - ruralisation of economy

Literary Evidence - Varahamihira's Brihatsamhita contains prophecy of depopulated and desolate cities. - In Ramayana, Ayodhya is said to have undergone urban decay after Rama's exile - Kalidasa's Raghuvamsa also describes desolated cities

No: There was no urban decay in 300-600 CE

Archaeological Evidence - The large scale building of temples like at Bhitargaon (Kanpur) or Udayagiri (M.P.) suggest an urban milieu - Excavations from Bhita reveal seals and sealings in large numbers from this period - markers of trade and commerce - Buddhist establishments like at Ajanta, Kanheri, Karle etc contain numerous donation inscriptions from merchants and traders from this period

Literary Evidence - The same Brihatsamhita contains descriptions of splendid cities replete with magnificent palaces - Mrichhakatika describes the gold and diamond studded gates and palace of Vasantasena in the city of Ujjaini - Kamasutra contains vivid descriptions of the suave, sophisticated and affluent city-dweller called 'nagaraka'

Given the vast expanse of the country, urban decay might have been a feature at few regions, while some regions might have flourished simultaneously.