Topper Copies

"On circumstantial evidence Indra stands accused." Discuss the given statement in the context of the decline of Harappan Civilisation.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

The above statement was given by Mortimer Wheeler, who argued strongly that an Aryan invasion was the cause of decline of the Harappan civilisation.

Aryan Invasion Theory : Myth or Reality? - Originally the theory was proposed by historian Ramaprasad Chanda and later elaborated by Mortimer Wheeler - Wheeler presented several arguments to support the claim such as reference to place 'Hariyupriya' in Vedas - Overwhelming references to wars, chariots, weapons, horses, etc in Vedic texts has been said to reflect war with Harappans - Epithet of 'Purandhara' - the breaker of forts, for God Indra was said to signify the same - Rig Vedic references to Dasas and Dasyus has been said to denote the Harappan peoples - A set of graves in upper layers of Mohenjodaro has been said to belong to the defeated Harappans - Wheeler has argued that Cemetery-H culture at Harappa belonged to first set of Aryan invaders - Hence according to this theory, the Aryan invaders with their superior military and techological advancements were responsible for the sudden decline of the Harappan civilisation

Recent Trends - Recently, the Aryan invasion theory has been under attack due to lack of compelling evidences - Archaeological evidence doesn't indicate presence of large scale weapons, charits, horse bones across major Harappan sites - Citadels - where a major fight could be expected - lacked graves, weapons, etc - KAR Kennedy's analysis of skeletal remains at Mohenjo-daro indicates they belonged to different times - The Cemetery-H culture doesn't show continuity with Harappan culture - Scholars like George Dales, PV Kane have questioned evidence from Vedic sources as they are religious texts with unclear age and authorship - Recent scholarship has rather moved towards environmental causes and climate change as the major reason for the decline - George Dales has argued that flooding of the Indus due to change in course could be a Reg reason. - M.R. Mughal's analysis shows drying in the Ghaggar - Hakra region

Recently, even study through mathematical models has revealed changes in climate towards end of the Harappan mature period, and the Aryan invasion theory for decline of Harappan civilisation largely stands rejected by scholars.