"Though the Permanent Settlement had serious defects, it gave tranquility to the countryside and stability to the government." Comment.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Permanent Settlement was introduced by lord Cornwallis to provide a systematic revenue collection machinery in Bengal.
As per Holmes (historian), Permanent settlement had serious defects :-
- Large increase in revenue demand - BB Chandhuri quantifies two times increase in revenue - Recognition of Zamindars as owners Diluted hereditary cultivation/tilling rights of tenants, exposing them to exploitation - Tripolarity of Exploitation [a triangle with "state" at the top, "peasant" inside near the top, "moneylender" at the bottom left and "landlord" at the bottom right] Peasant was demanded huge rent by landlord, depended on moneylender & state as bystander - Sunset Clause — around 41% of Zamindari owners denied landownership in 1790s-1800s (Daniel Thorner). Led to problem of 'absentee Landlordism', subinfeudation (14 patnidars) and commercialisation (Famine)
However, Permanent settlement provided tranquility in countryside & stability to govt.
- Zamindars as loyal allies who did govt bidding — collection of revenue, suppression of revolts. - State could depend on dependable source of revenue. - Expected Zamindars to advance agriculture by investment of surplus - Remove an elaborate zamindari machinery for tax collection— saving human & material resources
However, State was biggest loser in long run, making it search for alternate systems