Critically examine the turns and twists in the politics of partition in 1930's and 1940's.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The politics of partition refers to evolution of Two-State Theory in India, where a muslims demanded a separate state, a demand that intensified in 1930s & 1940s.
Politics of partition in 1930's & 1940's
- Pakistan's Idea - First floated through a Pamphlet by 'Chaudhury Rahmat Ali' Demand of separate muslim nation - PAKISTAN combining the muslim territories of North west for safety of Muslims - - [Jinnah's Dissatisfaction] 1) Congress Denial in Nehru Report of Delhi Proposals and 14 points regarding reservations to Muslims (even in majority areas) 2) [Provincial Election 1937] Muslim league did not perform well and was ignored by congress over suggestion of coalition, which was considered insult Jinnah turned to communal politics to make Muslim league relevant - [Muslim league Mobilisation] - Pirpur Committee to investigate on excesses on Muslims during Congress rule in states (69) denial of Islamic Education - Day of Deliverance - when congress ministries resigned - Formed coalition with Krishi Praja Party (Bengal) and Unionist Party in Punjab. were able to communalise the rural peasantry by blaming their plight on Hindus & risk of Hindu Majority state - 1940 Resolution - Demand of separate state called 'Pakistan Resolution' in Lahore Session - Virtual veto in constitutional discussion Muslim League took an uncompromising stance during Cripps mission, simla conference and Cabinet mission for demand of separate nation - Direct Action Day To force the British & Congress, started violent uprising in Bengal & Punjab in 1946. - [Failure of otheravenues] like Rajaji formula & Desai-Liaquat Pet
[why partition question evolved]
- Success- Failure Dichotomy of congress Failed to integrate Muslims in Indian nationalist discourse, despite obtaining freedom - Historians like Ayesha Jalal attribute congress failure to accomodate nationalists demands of Jinnah. He did not want partition but autonomy in Indian union (weak federal state) - Jawaharlal Nehru attributed it to delay in middle class formation in Muslims who got easily radicalised by Muslim League.
Thus, partition politics culminated into formation of Pakistan in 1947 with Jinnah as its Governor General, achieving his goal.