Critically examine Orientalism versus Anglicanism debate and how it was solved.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The Orientalism versus Anglicanism debate emerged with Charter Act, 1813 where allocation of Rs 1 Lakh was to be decided for education and advancement of India.
Orientalism vs Anglicanism Debate
Pre-1813 period | Domination of Orientalists in education scenario. Gyanvi Vishwanathan calls this period as reverse acculturation, where the dominant rulers attempted to learn about Indian culture and polity to create acceptability of their rule. Orientalists like HH Wilson and HT Princep encouraged. learning of Indian languages,
- Political system based on existing Indian system (Eg) Sadr Diwani Adalat Sadr Nijamat used personal laws - Created institutions like Calcutta Madarsa, Sanskrit college (Jonathan Duncan) and Asiatic society of Bengal to Further Indic studies.
[Post -1813] Increasing demand of Utilitarians and Evangelists to enhance western Education in India
- [Reason] - civilising Mission and inferiority of Indian culture vis-a-vis West - Evangelists saw it opportunity to expand christianity (Charles Trevelyan)
However, whether Orientalist, Amherst or Evangelist - ultimate motive to expand British rule & sustain it.
Resolution of Orientalist Anglicist Debate
Lord Macaulay seeked to resolve the debate as the chairman of General Committee of public Instruction.
| Orientalist Argument | Anglicist Argument | |---|---| | Scholarships as source of livelihood for students = 8000 Mohammedans protested their stoppage | Indians ready to pay for education while scholarships for Indian education burden on Company | | Breach of trust with Indians - against ethos of British rule | western education provides employment to Indians | | English too foreign a language for Indians to learn | 'One single shelf of English literature worth more than entire Indian Culture | | Indians will accept the inferiority of their education & accept western Education | Demand of Indians for western education (eg Raja Ram Mohan Roy) | | Educating wider population in Vernacular language | limited education with educated Indian entending it in English |
Final Result
1) Macaulay's Minute decided Western Literature & philosophy, taught in English to limited section (who can pay) 2) Schools established in provinces 3) European Teachers, missionary schools
As per Sabyasachi Chatterjee, the western education involved decline of Indian Education and responsibility of imposing education to the Metropolitan centre & spreading it to local centres