Topper Copies

"The Dual System of Government led to the power being divorced from responsibility, lawlessness, heightened abuse of private trade, severe oppression of peasantry and was a complete failure but still it can be considered as political sagacity of Clive." Examine.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

Post British Victory in Battle of Buxar (1764), Robert Clive established system of Dual Government for Bengal's administration.

P. Spears remarked it was a system of 'sponsored state' where British had all the power but no responsibility.

Clauses of Dual Government

Instituted through Treaty of Allahabad 1764:-

1) Diwani received 'Diwani' of Bihar Bengal and Orissa for ₹26 lakh to Mughal Emperor 2) Nizamat of Bengal given to 'Nawab of Bengal' but indirectly exercised by British East India Company for Rs 54 lakh 3) Officials Deputy subahdar appointed Mohammad Reza Khan and Raja Sitab Roy accountable to British EIC.

Weakness of Dual Government

- Power Divorced from Responsibility Nawab was given responsibility to maintain Bengal But had no authority. British exercised all power through deputies and undertook no responsibility - Lawlessness Law and order declined because Nawab lacked authority and British Company lacked political will - - Abuse of private trade At hands of company officials isolated and coerced the traders and artisans in India. Decline of Bengal handicraft & trade by mercantalist policies and monopoly over internal trade - Severe oppression of Peasantry Over assessment of revenue demand and harshness of collection pauperised peasants. situation aggravated by failure of crops and severe famine in 1769-1770 causing largescale demise in Bengal Company officials took no care of plight of peasants and undertook forced collections. - Complete failure - corruption and private trade enriched officials but bankrupted company. On verge of failure to pay £40000 for maintaining monopoly

Political Sagacity of Clive

- Parliamentary Interference - Did not enforce direct control to reduce parliamentary control on company - Appease natives & Europeans Threat of other Indian rulers forming a coalition against nascent British control Europeans (French) refusing to pay dues to British - Lack of officials - Had limited officials with low understanding of Indian culture & administration

Thus, KM Pannikar rightly called the Dual Govt as Hobbes state as it reduced Bengal to anarchy and chaos.