Critically examine the debates among historians regarding the applicability of the term 'Indian Feudalism' to early Medieval Society.
Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025
The early medieval society in India roughly spans the period 700AD - 1200AD. Marxist historians had argued that this period was a period of Indian Feudalism.
Applicability of Term Indian Feudalism to Early Medieval Period
1. Marxist View - Views of historians like D.D. Kosambi and R.S Sharma - They argue it was a period of feudalism- marked by heirarchy of land rights - There was rise of landed intermediaries called by titles like Ranaka, Thakura, Samanta, etc - Age was marked by urban decay and ruralisation - For ex. excavation from Vaishali from this period point towards poor construction of houses - Plenty of land grant inscriptions of rulers like Pratiharas, Chalukyas point towards feudalism - There was monetary anaemia leading to decline of trade and commerce - Economy was largely self-sufficient
Counter-Views - D.C. Sarkar was the first to argue against theory of Indian Feudalism - Subsequently, B.D. Chattopadhyaya put forward clinching arguments: - Argued that while some cities declined, many cities also enjoyed prosperity as of indicated by Literary sources - Since the 5th century AD was marked by rise in urbanisation , he posed the question that how can all of a sudden deurbanisation occur - Herman Kulke has argued that it was period of 'segmentary states' - when only ritual kingship existed - The local units were largely autonomous and accepted suzerainty of ritual king - The sovereignty was established through tribute but no centralised bureaucracy existed - R.N. Chaudhury has argued against monetary anaemia - and says coinage in the form Harikela silver coins and Churni existed - Harbans Mukhia has argued Indian soil was very fertile and European style manorialism didn't exist in India - John .S. Deyell shows that while quality of coins degraded, the quantity of coin in this period was still high
Final Verdict - Recent regional studies have established that situation varied spatially and temporally - In east, Cowrie shells shells were used as a form of exchange - Siyodari inscription mentions various types of coins - By 900 AD, there was revival of some urban centres
It may be appropriate to conclude that given India's huge size and geography, fitting the entire period into rigid models may not be wise. Rather history should be seen from the perspective of a process.