Topper Copies

"The advent of the Mauryan dynasty marks the passage from darkness to the light for the historians." Explain the perspective of the historian V.A. Smith.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

VA Smith appreciates Mauryan dynasty as epochal moment in Indian history due to rich sources available for understanding them.

Mauryan Dynasty -> Passage from Darkness to light - Literary sources : like Arthashastra for polity and statecraft, Indica by Mega-sthenes, Mudrarakshasa for Chandragupta's history. Divyavamsa & Dipavamsa for Buddhist foundations in Mauryas - Establish chronology : based on information provided by literary and archeological sources and genealogy of rulers - Inscription by Ashoka : Direct view into mind of Ashoka as his edicts are in first person format - Extent of Empire : Ashokan edicts spread from south (Brahmagiri) to North (Langpaka), west (Kandahar, Sopara, Girnar) to East (Jaugada) - foreign relations ⇒ Based on information in Greek texts (through Indica) → Justin and Strabo have given rich account of Mauryas - Archeological Remains ⇒ like NBPW culture reflects rich material culture in Mauryan Empire. - Nature of state ⇒ Arthasastra talks about universalistic bureaucratic system reflecting Centralised administration

Limitation of Mauryan sources for history - Authorship of Arthasastra - Upinder Singh reflects about whether 'Chanakya', 'Kautilya' & 'Vishnugupta' are same person - Debates by Patrick Olivelle and Mark McClish about period of Arthasastra as Post Mauryan due to 'coral trade' with west - 'Indica' of Megasthenes ⇒ Has many incorrect information like society in 7 classes, money lending famine - Nature of state ⇒ Historians like Gerard Fergusson donot accept centralised administration for Mauryas.

There are still some 'dark' aspects that need further analysis & discussions for clarity on aspects of Mauryan period -