"Roots of the concept of Ashoka's Dhamma can found in Vedic—Upanishadic literature." Discuss.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The Ashokan Edicts provide information about Ashokas Dhamma, which have been linked to Vedic-upanishad ideas by historians like DN Jha and Romila Thapar
Vedic-upanishad literature as Root of Ashoka's Dhamma Commonalities in ideas of Ahimsa - Vedic-Upanishad favoured 'Ahimsa' and harmonious life with animals written by Vanaprastha priests, supported coexistence over violence - Ashokan Edict → Major Rock Edict II supported non-violence towards animals
Opinion about rituals - upanishads opposed rituals for achieving salvation - Rock Edict IX supported following Dhamma instead of performing ritual especially by women.
Mutual Tolerance - Both ideas display universalistic and inclusionist aspects regarding different beliefs
Focus on righteousness - 'satya' in 'Satyamev Jayate' from Chandogya upanishad adopted in lion capital of Sarnath built by Ashoka
Respect for elders & Brahmanas - mentioned in Rock Edict III, justifying the vedic-Upanishad texts regarding reverence to knowledgeable members of society
Distinction between Vedic-Upanishad literature & Ashoka's Dhamma - Supported by upinder singh ⇒ Ashoka's Dhamma, despite inspirations from upanishads have its specific aspects of reign & personal beliefs - Dhamma was for ethical life (HC Rayachaudhuri) or possible political stability (Romila Thapar) while upanishads focused on achieving 'Moksha' and relief from cycle of birth & death. Dhamma does not speak of Moksha - Dhamma, through Edict VI, V and VIII support Buddhism (S J Tambiah) as underlying inspiration. Pali Canon term Ashoka as devoted upasaka.
Thus, Vedic upanishads texts inspired Dhamma but with time it evolved its own identity as guide for Mauryan empire