"An ideology of paternalistic benevolence, sometimes coupled with rhetoric of trusteeship and preparation for self-government, barely masked the stark realities of a Raj that was firmly white and autocratic." Critically examine.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The British rule has been considered as an outcome of 'providential mission', 'a white man's burden' for justifying the autocratic and exploitative control of India.
British Ideology of Indian colonialism
Paternalistic Benevolence - JS Mills claimed British control of India will help in civilising it. He considered 'superiority of Indian civilisation as myth by susceptible imaginations of men like william Jones.
Trusteeship - Apologists like Morison D Monies called Position as night watchmen who focused an propelling India's growth in its economic stagnancy.
Self Government - Argued by Company rule by proclaiming rules temporary control. Reiterated by Montford Statement in 1917.
White and Autocratic Nature of British Rule
1. Poor sharing of power - no participation of Indians in governance till 1861, appointed mainly loyalists 2. Discrimination in services - higher positions reserved for Europeans, Indian paid low wages and suffered racism 3. Drain of wealth - As per Dada Bhai Naoroji - Around £120 million drained per year - suppressed development of Indian industries and destroyed traditional handicrafts.
Thus, despite claims of British, every section of Britain derived benefit from India's exploitation while suppressing it brutally for force and autocratic legislations (Eg. Press Acts).