Topper Copies

"The Gupta period is considered as a "Golden Age" but the common masses lived in misery." Examine. [20 Marks]

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

AL Basham calls the Gupta period as 'Golden Age' for its imperialism, administration and cultural pursuits, while Marxist historians (Kosambi, Jha) call it exploitative for common people.

Gupta Period as "Golden Age"

- Extent of Empire From North India to Deccan [an outline map of India with the northern and central part hatched, boxed and labelled "Gupta-Vakataka Age"] - Matrimonial alliances => Prabhavati Gupta with Rudrasena - Conquest => Samudragupta as Napoleon of India (VA Smith) => Prayag Prashasti - Administration AL Basham has appreciated administrative efficiency - Collection of taxes => Kara, hiranyaya, Bhaga, bali, hali - Agriculture => Focus on agricultural improvement (Paharpur inscription) - Culture 1. Coinage - "The sophistication of Gupta coinage not replicated in future India" - i) rich purity - 70% - 90%. - ii) Artistic significance - Samudragupta's lion coin, horse type, veena etc. - iii) Royal heritage - King & queen coin 2. Architecture rise of Pre-Nagara temple architecture eg Dashavatara Temple (Deogarh), Bhitargaon Panchayatan style. 3. Religion | Puranic Hinduism - rise of Vaishnavism, Shaivism, Shaktism. Fa Hien commented on flourishing Buddhist centres - Sravasti, Kausambi 4. Literature - polity - Dandaniti, Nitisara Epics Drama - Abhigyanasakuntalam / Vikramorvashi (Kalidasa) Navaratnas for Chandragupta II.

Common people in Gupta Empire

Marxist historians feel the reference to "Golden period" was elitist and incomplete - Chandalas Fa Hien mentioned poor conditions of Chandalas in Foo Kuki. Showed Varna based discrimination had increased and rigidity in society increased - Patriarchy rise in patriarchal rigidity with reference to Sati (Eran Inscription under Bhanugupta) - Narada Smriti called adultery by women as sin punishable with strictness - Manusmriti supported prepubertty marriage and against widow remarriage - Deurbanization R S Sharma in 'Indian feudalism' refered to 300-600 AD as decline of urban centres - Mandsaur Inscription - silk weavers took up agriculture decline in Roman Trade - Literary - decline of Ayodhya references (Ramayana), Raghuvamsa etc.

Rise in land grants, monetary paucity created intermediaries who exacted control on residents of land through vishti

Romila Thapar takes a middle approach where accepting of advancements during Guptas, highlights the social decline that inevitable affected future India.