Analyse the various causes which were responsible for the partition of India.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The 'Partition of India is the most discursive territory of South Asian Historiography with scholars blaming Muslim League, Congress or causes of events in history.
Causes of Partition of India
1. Communalism and its Evolution - Historians remark Congress had twofold objective - (i) To achieve independence and (ii) String together India's diversity into a nation. - Congress failed in second goal - with tacit acceptance of Muslim League as separate political entity (Lucknow Pact, Rajaji Formula) 2. British policies of Divide and Rule - to preserve their control over India. - Eg. Separate electorates (Morley Minto Reform 1909), Virtual veto in discussions (Eg. Wavell Plan - Shimla Conference) 3. Muslim League - Emerged to safeguard Muslim interests and evolved to demand separate nationality - i) Chaudhary Rahmat Ali Pamphlet for 'PAKISTAN' - i) Pakistan resolution in 1940 - It incited communal tendencies of India by emphasising on Muslim identity, declared Congress as Hindu Party and called for direct Action Day. 4. Immediate Events of 1940s - Non-Cooperation by Muslim league and impending withdrawal of British created matter of urgency. - Jawahar Lal Nehru and Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel were concerned about law and order situation. - They were wary of 'small pockets of Pakistan' emerging in other sections/regions of India. 5. Quid Pro Quo - Expediency of British withdrawal required control of Indian affairs with Indians. - Mountbatten promised to make Pakistan as small as possible, Hyderabad not to join Pakistan and Princely states to join Pakistan in return of acceptance 6. Smaller but Stable Nation - As per Ayesha Jalal, Indian nationalists accepted Partition to create a smaller but stable nation, with more centralisation and control with union Govt than possible with inclusion of Pakistan territories.
Over time, Partition historiography has shifted from its causes to its consequences. Partition occured due to mix of misgivings of Indian nationalists, Muslim league and British Government. Nevertheless, it caused displacement and death of million and one of the tragic chapters of history.