"If abdication of British responsibility at the time of transfer of power was callous, the speed with which it was done made it worse." Critically examine.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The statement of Clement Attley of withdrawal from India aimed to give a shock to Indians into action in 1946, with impending withdrawal to any government by 1948.
The British decided to transfer power to India with enactment of India Independence Act of 1947, provision of Boundary Commission under Cyril Radcliff and decided date of withdrawal of 15 August 1947.
Callous nature of British abdication
(i) Boundary Commission - Cyril Radcliff was an advocate with no exposure to India - Given old maps and given less time to provide a harmonious solution to partition problem.
(2) Did not transfer paramountcy of Successor government - Problem of Kashmir, Hyderabad etc..
(3) Lack of British administrative support to affected functioning of nascent governments.
Speed of British abdication aggravated crisis
(1) Partition - led to refugee crisis (Prafulla Chakraborthy - around 1.1 million moved from West Bengal)
ii) Anarchy for women - As per Ritu Menon - women had no choice but to be raped, killed or commit suicide to save honour
(2) Misgovernance - Law and order issues due to apathetic withdrawal of British administration
However, British had little choice. As per Lord Wavell, administration of India without cooperation of Indians had become difficult. Further it was adding on financial weakness of Britain. Nevertheless, British withdrawal was inefficiently executed and caused great mayhem in late 1940s.